Portuguese Prepper
Gravity Filters vs. Pump Filters: Which is best for groups?
When filtering water for more than one person, squeeze pouches and straws become exhausting.
High-volume filtration relies on two main mechanisms: Gravity Systems (passive hanging bags) and Pump Filters (manual action).
For 90% of preppers and families, a Gravity System is the superior choice because it requires zero effort once set up.
However, Pump Filters remain essential for specific scenarios where water sources are shallow or difficult to reach.
Gravity systems filter 2-4 liters at once while you do other tasks.
Pump filters work instantly but require continuous physical effort.
Pumps are better for shallow puddles; Gravity bags need to be scooped/filled.
The “Basecamp” Solution: Gravity Filters
Gravity filters (like the Platypus GravityWorks or Katadyn BeFree) consist of a “dirty” bag and a “clean” bag connected by a hose. You hang the dirty bag from a tree or door frame, and gravity forces water through the filter.
They are silent, hands-free, and ideal for bugging in or setting up a temporary camp. The downside? You need a water source deep enough to scoop the “dirty” bag full.
The “Scavenger” Solution: Pump Filters
Pump filters (like the Katadyn Hiker Pro) use an inlet hose with a small bobber. You throw the hose into the water and pump a handle to force water through a ceramic or pleated filter.
Their superpower is shallow water. You can pump water out of a tiny rock puddle or a crack in the pavement where you couldn’t possibly submerge a gravity bag. If your environment is arid or urban, a pump is often more versatile.
Which system fits your scenario?
Maintenance Reality Check
Gravity filters usually require “back-flushing” (running clean water backward) to clear clogs. Pump filters often require scrubbing the element or replacing a pre-filter screen. Both require more maintenance than simple tablets, but they provide immediate, taste-free water.
Related pages
Affiliate disclosure: We test and review survival gear. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.